Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2: Which smart scale is right for you?
Discover the ideal scale for your lifestyle by comparing battery life, health features, and advanced features of the Withings Body Smart vs...
Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan: A comprehensive comparison
When you're evaluating options like the Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan, understanding the nuances of each scale can significantly impact your health and fitness journey. This comparison will delve into the key differences to help you choose the best body composition scale for your needs.
Body Scan
The incredible health checkup
$499.95
Battery
Rechargeable, up to 1 year
Weight
Segmental body composition
3-frequency body composition scan
Fat, muscle, water & bone mass
50g of weight precision
Basal Metabolic Rate
Visceral fat
BMI
-
Heart
Heart rate
Vascular Age
6-lead ECG¹
Atrial fibrillation detection¹
Electrodermal activity
Electrodermal activity score
Evaluate the natural protective function of the skin
Design
High-strength tempered glass platform
Retractable handle
High resolution LCD color screen
Connectivity
Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby & Eyes-Closed Modes
AutoSync+™ via Wi-Fi & Bluetooth
Tanita RD-545HR
Improve your performance
$449.99
Battery
AA batteries, approximatively 1 year
Weight
Segmental body composition
2-frequency body composition scan
Fat, muscle, water & bone mass
50g of weight precision
Basal Metabolic Rate
Visceral fat
BMI
Muscle quality
Heart
Heart rate
-
-
-
Electrodermal activity
-
-
Design
Plastic
Retractable handle
LED screen
Connectivity
Guest and athlete modes
Bluetooth connection
Premium design that elevates your health journey
Comparing the Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan, one of the initial distinctions is design. The Withings Body Scan scale boasts a sleek, modern aesthetic that seamlessly integrates into any home. Crafted with premium materials, its minimalist glass platform, large high-resolution LCD color screen, and retractable handle offer a high-end user experience from the first interaction with the body scan. In contrast, the Tanita scale, while highly functional, utilizes a design that some may find bulkier, potentially making it feel less harmonious within a home setting.
A well-designed body composition scale should feel intuitive and effortless, enhancing your health journey — and that’s precisely what Withings Body Scan aims to deliver.
Built-in rechargeable battery: A smarter use of time
Unlike the Tanita RD-545 HR, which requires regular battery replacements, the Withings Body Scan is equipped with a rechargeable battery — a key advantage in the Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan consideration that saves both money and time.
With the Withings scale, you’ll spend less time worrying about power and more time focusing on your health and fitness goals. The USB-C charging ensures long-lasting use, and a single charge can power the scale for months. This makes the Withings Body Scan not just smarter but also more sustainable. When considering which of these advanced scales best fits a modern lifestyle, the convenience of its power source and efficient use of your time are not to be overlooked.
Health insights beyond fat and weight
While both scales provide advanced body composition metrics like fat percentage, muscle mass, and weight, Withings Body Scan goes further by offering insights into heart health and nerve activity. It doesn't just track your fitness; it supports your entire body’s well-being with ECG recordings and segmental body composition analysis. The Tanita RD-545 HR, though an advanced tool for body composition, focuses primarily on athletic performance and detailed fitness metrics. The Withings scale, on the other hand, is built for anyone who wants a holistic view of their health, making its scan capabilities a smarter choice for understanding your body in the long term.
Learn more about Body Scan:
Body Scan
The scale that revolutionizes home health checkups.
Compatible with iOS 16+ & Android 9.0+
Metrics tracked
Weight
Four weight sensors
Precise weight measurements (0.1lbs)
Body Composition
Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis (BIA) Multifrequency
Units: body fat %, total body water %, muscle mass kg or lb, bone mass kg or lb, Visceral Fat Index, Basal Metabolic Rate
Multi-user friendly
Automatically recognizes and tracks up to 8 users
Features tailored modes, including Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby and Eyes Closed
Connectivity
App
Wireless Sync
WiFi 802.11 b/g/n, compatible with WEP/WPA/WPA2-personal networks
Bluetooth connectivity (Bluetooth Smart Ready)
Requirements
Body Scan can be installed on a smartphone or a tablet, via the Withings app available on iOS (iOS 15 and higher) and Android (10.0 and higher).
Cannot be set up from a computer
Device
Four weight sensors
Weight range: 5-200 kg (9-440 lbs)
50 g (0.1lb) precision
Units: kg, lb, st lb
Patented body position detector
Highly-accurate weigh-ins via Position ControlTM technology
Scale
High-strength tempered glass platform
Dimensions: 12.8 x 12.8 x 1.1 in. / 325 x 325 x 25,6 mm
Display
Clear, easy to see graphical display (2.8”), 320 x 240 pixels
High resolution LCD color screen
Storage and memory
Free and unlimited storage of weight data
Stores up to 16 weigh-ins at one time if the scale cannot sync wirelessly
Power supply
Rechargeable Li-ion battery
Average battery life: up to 1 year per charge
Free shipping
30-day trial
2-year warranty
More infos about the Withings+ subscription
The Withings+ subscription unlocks an in-app health experience with access to daily engagement support and exclusive content in the areas of sleep, nutrition and activity. With Withings+, you will be guided on a daily basis to create a healthy routine that sticks.
Promotional Offers of Withings+ subscription bundled with a Body Scan health station
For the launch of the Body Scan health station, we offer two introductory Withings+ subscription plans (1)(2):
- Open-ended subscription with monthly payment: 3 free months of Withings+, then 9.95$/month (3)
- Open-ended subscription with monthly payment: 3 free months of Withings+, then 99.5$/year (4)
The 3-months trial period starts on the product’s installation using the Withings mobile application.
(1) These introductory offers are not mandatory to use the Body Scan health station. By selecting one of these offers, you agree to conclude a subscription contract with Withings for the Withings+ service with the terms and conditions described below and our General Terms and Conditions of Sales. The contract will start upon Body Scan health station installation using the Withings mobile application.
(2) Offer reserved for new Withings+ subscribers only (any person not subscribed to Withings+ service during the last twelve (12) months).
(3) Right after the 3-month trial period, the monthly payment starts and you will be automatically charged 9.95€ (or $9.95 or £8.95) per month.
(4) Right after the 3-month trial period, the annual payment starts and you will be automatically charged 99.5€ (or $99.5 or £89.5) per year.
You can unsubscribe at any time following the procedure described in our General Terms and Conditions of Sales
Product sheet relative to the environmental impact
Environmental impact of the packaging:
Packaging made with a minimum of 65% recycled material
Most packaging is recyclable
Environmental impact of the product:
Product contains at least 40mg of precious metals
FAQ: Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan
Which is better for health tracking: Tanita RD-545 HR or Withings Body Scan?
In the Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan decision, the Withings Body Scan offers a more complete view of your health. This scale includes detailed body composition measuring fat, muscle, and weight), heart health insights, and nerve activity, while the Tanita RD-545 HR focuses mainly on fitness metrics with a lot of details about body composition.
Does the Withings Body Scan need batteries like the Tanita RD-545 HR?
No, the Withings Body Scan scale features a rechargeable battery, offering more convenience over time and saving you from the recurring cost and effort associated with disposable batteries, which the Tanita RD-545 HR requires.
Is there a difference in design between Tanita RD-545 HR vs Withings Body Scan?
Yes, the Withings Body Scan has a more modern, premium look compared to the bulkier design of the Tanita RD-545 HR. But both offer a retractable handle to better analyze body composition.
Can both scales measure fat and body composition?
Yes, both the Tanita RD-545 HR and Withings Body Scan scales measure fat, weight, and body composition, but only the Withings scale enhances its scan by adding cardiovascular and nervous system monitoring to its composition analysis.
Which scale is easier to use over time?
The Withings Body Scan is generally considered more convenient for long-term use, thanks to its rechargeable battery and intuitive free app. These features save users valuable time while helping them manage their health and fitness data gathered from the scale’s comprehensive body scan.
¹Via ECG Monitor available on Body Scan
Muscle mass scales
Explore our muscle mass scales from Withings. Accurately monitor your body composition and achieve your fitness goals with advanced...
Body Fat Scales: Accurate Health Tracking
Discover our body fat scales from Withings. Accurately track your body composition and reach your fitness goals with advanced technology...
Body fat percentage: Understanding and measuring body fat
Learn what body fat percentage is, how to measure it accurately, and discover healthy ranges and lifestyle tips to reduce excess body fat.
Benefit from a 10% discount
on your first order by registering
By registering, you agree to receive advertising e-mails from Withings. However, if you change your mind, you can unsubscribe at any time. *The discount is valid for any purchase (except BPM Vision) of at least €100 for 30 days after reception of the code. Only valid on withings.com, and while supplies last. This offer is only valid for first-time purchases. These offers cannot be combined.
