Body Fat Scales: Accurate Health Tracking
Discover our body fat scales from Withings. Accurately track your body composition and reach your fitness goals with advanced technology...
Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2: A comprehensive comparison
Navigating the choice between the Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2? You're in good company. In the competitive world of smart scales, both the Withings Body Smart and the Garmin Index S2 are prominently connected devices, yet they cater to distinct user profiles and health goals. Whether you're an athlete focused on peak performance or an individual seeking a holistic view of your well-being, understanding how each smart scale integrates into your lifestyle—and your existing ecosystem of apps and devices—is key to making the right choice. This comparison will help you see which device best aligns with your needs for tracking your body metrics.
Body Smart
The powerful checkup for reaching your goals
99,95€
Battery
AAA batteries, approximately 18-month battery life
Weight
Advanced body composition
Fat, muscle, water & bone mass
50g of weight precision
Basal Metabolic Rate
Visceral fat
BMI
Heart
Heart rate
Design
High-strength tempered glass platform
High resolution LCD color screen
Connectivity
Athlete, Pregnancy, Baby & Eyes-Closed Modes
AutoSync+™ via Wi-Fi & Bluetooth
Garmin Index S2
It’s not just about what you weigh
149,99€
Battery
AAA batteries, approximately 9-month battery life
Weight
Body composition
Fat, muscle, water & bone mass
100g of weight precision
-
-
BMI
Heart
-
Design
Plastic
LED screen
Connectivity
Weight-only mode
Wi-Fi connection
Withings: A smarter smart scale for everyday health
The Withings Body Smart transcends the typical smart scale; it's a clinically evaluated health companion meticulously designed for anyone aiming to deeply understand their body. If you're looking to track weight, muscle mass, or your complete body composition, the Withings Body Smart offers a comprehensive experience, often at a more accessible price point than the Garmin Index S2.
Unlike Garmin, which often targets athletes with its high-performance tracking, Withings serves a wider audience focused on general fitness, wellness, and proactive health management. Through its seamless free app integration and automatic data syncing, users can also see trends and improvements over time across the entire Withings ecosystem—connecting data from smart scales to smartwatches for a holistic view.
Premium design and long-lasting battery life
In the Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2 debate, design and battery life are significant differentiators. The Withings Body Smart boasts a sleeker, more premium aesthetic that seamlessly integrates into your home decor. And when it comes to power? With the Withings Body Smart, you get extended battery life that far exceeds what Garmin offers, ensuring consistent health data tracking without frequent interruptions.
Furthermore, Withings' smart scale allows you to analyze detailed body composition, including muscle mass, fat percentage, and water levels, plus standing heart rate and visceral fat, giving you a complete picture of your internal metrics. This goes far beyond just body weight, making it a powerful tool not just for fitness enthusiasts, but for anyone committed to long-term health improvements.
Smart scale features that work for you
Whether you're tracking your fitness goals, watching your weight, or simply trying to live healthier, the Withings Body Smart adapts to your needs. It works seamlessly with the free Withings app, giving you easy access to all your historical data and insights. This integration is especially beneficial if you're already using other Withings products, like hybrid smartwatches or blood pressure monitors, as all your health metrics come together in a single, easy-to-use ecosystem.
In contrast, the Garmin Index requires syncing with the Garmin app, which is more focused on athletic performance than holistic wellness. If your goal is a smart scale that tracks comprehensive health data—not solely workout metrics—the Withings Body Smart emerges as the more versatile and insightful choice for overall body well-being.
FAQ – Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2
What’s the main difference between Withings Body Smart and Garmin Index S2?
Withings Body Smart offers more features, including detailed body composition analysis (like muscle mass) and standing heart rate, often for a lower price. It's also clinically evaluated and better suited for general health tracking, while Garmin Index S2 is more focused on fitness and athletic users. When considering Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2, these distinctions in features and target audience are key.
Can both smart scales track muscle mass?
Yes, both the Withings Body Smart and Garmin Index S2 smart scales track muscle mass as part of their body composition features. However, Withings Body Smart offers better integration within the comprehensive Withings ecosystem for a fuller picture of your health data.
Which scale has better battery life between Withings Body Smart vs Garmin Index S2?
Withings Body Smart wins here, offering significantly longer battery life (up to 18 months) than the Garmin Index S2, which requires more frequent battery replacements. This means less interruption to your health and weight tracking.
Is the Withings app better than Garmin’s?
Both Withings and Garmin apps offer detailed insights and data. However, the Withings app shines in its user-friendly design and ability to consolidate multiple health metrics—including weight, muscle, sleep, and cardiovascular data— in one place within its ecosystem. Users often see this as a major advantage.
Which smart scale is best for general health tracking: Withings Body Smart or Garmin Index S2?
If you're looking for one of the top smart scales to help you monitor not just fitness, but your overall health and body composition (including muscle mass and weight), the Withings Body Smart is generally the better option. It’s designed for everyday users seeking comprehensive health data, not just athletes, and offers unmatched value within the Withings ecosystem.
Muscle mass scales: Precise tracking solutions
Explore our muscle mass scales from Withings. Accurately monitor your body composition and achieve your fitness goals with advanced...
Healthy body composition: What it is and how to improve it
What is body composition? Learn how to measure it, what defines a healthy body composition, and tips to improve your fat, muscle, and water...
Body fat percentage: Understanding and measuring body fat
Learn what body fat percentage is, how to measure it accurately, and discover healthy ranges and lifestyle tips to reduce excess body fat.
Benefit from a 10% discount
on your first order by registering
By registering, you agree to receive advertising e-mails from Withings. However, if you change your mind, you can unsubscribe at any time. *The discount is valid for any purchase (except BeamO and U-Scan Nutrio) of at least €100 for 30 days after reception of the code. Only valid on withings.com, and while supplies last. This offer is only valid for first-time purchases. These offers cannot be combined.